Sulaimaan Bin Musa Muhaddiseen ki Nazar me.

Sulaimaan Bin Musa Rh.
Muhaddiseen ki Nazar me.

Sulaimaan Bin Musa Ad-
Dimishqi Fuqaaha aur
Muhaddiseen ke Nazdeek
Zaeef, Munkar ul Hadees,
Muztarib ul Hadees Qism ka
raavi hai.
Unke bare Muhaddiseen ke
Aqwaal Mulaaheza Farmaaye..

1 – Imam Bukhari Rh.
Farmaate hai ke Munkar ul
Hadees hai. (Elal e Tirmizi
Kabeer : Safa 257, Hadees no
473)

2 – Imam Abu Haatim Rh.
Farmaate hai ke Sach-chayi
uska Mahel hai aur Uski Baaz
Hadeeso me Isteraab hai. (Al
Jarah Wa Ta’adeel : Jild 4 :
Safa 142, Raqm no 615)

3 – Imam Nasaai Rh. Farmaate
hai ke Hadees me Qawi nahi
hai. (Al Ikmaal Tehzeeb ul
Kamaal : Jild 6 : Safa 99)

4 – Imam Abu Arb Rh.
Farmaate hai ke Usme Nazar
hai. (Al Ikmaal Tehzeeb ul
Kamaal : Jild 6 : Safa 100)

5 – Imam Zuhri Rh. Farmaate
hai ke Uske paas Ajeeb
ahadees hai. (Al Ikmaal
Tehzeeb ul Kamaal : Jild 6 :
Safa 99)

6 – Imam Tirmizi Rh. Farmaate
hai ke USKE PAAS MUNKAR
AHADEES HAI. (Elal e Tirmizi
Kabeer : Safa 257, Hadees no
473)

7 – Imam Nasaai rh. Farmaate
hai ke Uski Hadeese me Kuch
[Kalaam] hai. (Tehzeeb ul
Kamaal : Jild 12 : Safa 97)

8 – Imam Ibn Abdul Barr Rh.
Farmaate hai ke wo Bure
Hafize Waala hai. (Al
Eztazkaar : Jild 15 : Safa 204)

9 – Ibn Juraij Rh. Kehte hai ke
Mere Nazdeek Uski Ahadees
Ajeeb hai. (Taarekh ul Ausat
Lil Bukhari : Jild 1 : Safa 304)

10 – Imam Bukhari rh.
Farmaate hai ke Mere Nazdeek
Munkar Riwayate Naql karne
waala hai. (Tehzeeb ul
Kamaal : Jild 12 : Safa 97 )

11 – Imam Mardeeni Rh.
Farmaate hai ke Mutakallam
Fihi Raavi hai aur Unki Is
(Qurbaani waali) Hadees me
Saqt Isteraab hai Jisko Imam
Ibn Abdul Barr Rh. ne Bayaan
kiya hai. (Al Johar un Naqi :
Jild 9 : Safa 296)

12 – Imam Ali bin Madeeni Rh.
Farmaate hai ke Unpar Kalaam
kiya gaya hai. (Zuaafa e
Uqaili : Jild 2 : Safa 506)

13 – Imam Ibn Hibban Rh.
Farmaate hai ke Uski Tamaam
Khabre Tadlees ki huwi hai. (Al
Mashaahir ul Ulama ul
Amsaar : Safa 210, Raqm no
1415)

14 – Imam Saaji Rh. Farmaate
hai ke Mere Nazdeek Munkar
Riwayate Naql karne waala
hai. (Al Ikmaal Tehzeeb ul
Kamaal : Jild 6 : Safa 100)

15 – Imam Ahmed Al Haakim
Rh. Farmaate hai ke Uski Baaz
Ahadees me Munkir hai. (Al
Ikmaal Tehzeeb ul Kamaal :
Jild 6 : Safa 99)

16 – Imam Sufiyan Rh.
Farmaate hai ke Kabhi Munkar
Baat Naql Karte hai aur Kabhi
Sabse Hat Kar (Ikhtelaafi
Baat) Naql Karte hai. (Al
Ikmaal Tehzeeb ul Kamaal :
Jild 6 : Safa 100)

17 – Imam Bukhari Rh.,
18 – Imam Nasaai Rh.,
19 – Imam Ibn Jarood Rh.,
20 – Imam Zehbi Rh.,
21 – Imam Uqaili Rh., aur
22 – Imam Ibn ul Jauzi Rh. ne
Unko apni Apni Kitaab uz
Zuaafa me Naql Karke Zaeef
Qaraar diya hai.
(Zuaafa e Sagheer Lil
Bukhari : Safa 55, Raqm no
146)
(Zuaafa Wal Matrookin Lin
Nasaai : Safa 186, Raqm no
252)
(Al Ikmaal Tehzeeb ul Kamaal :
Jild 6 : Safa 100)
(Deewan e Zuaafa Wal
Matrookin Liz Zehbi : Safa
176, Raqm no 1783)
(Zuaafa e Kabeer Lil Uqaili :
Jild 2 : Safa 506, Raqm no
632)
(Zuaafa wal Matrookin Lil Ibn
ul Jauzi : Jild 2 : Safa 25,
Raqm no 1549)

23 – Imam Zehbi Rh. ne Apni
Ek aur Kitaab Al Mughni Fil
Zuaafa me Is Raavi ko
Shumaar karke Zaeef Qaraar
diya hai. (Al Mughni Fil
Zuaafa : Jild 1 : Safa 408,
Raqm no 2630)

Lehaaza Sulaimaan Bin Musa
Ad-Dimishqi Rh. Zaeef aur
Munkar Riwayate Naql karne
waala hai.
Qususan Imam Bukhari rh. ne
Munkar ul Hadees Qaraar diya
hai aur Ghair Muqallideen ke
Nazdeek Jis Raavi ko Imam
Bukhari Rh. Munkar ul Hadees
Qaraar de, Uski riwayat
Qaabil e Aitebaar Nahi Hoti

Ajeeb baat phir Unki Riwayaat
se Har Chote aur Bade, Aalim
aur Ghair e Aalim ghair
Muqallid Ahle-hadees Istedlaal
Karta hai Seene pe Haat
Bandhne ke Masle par aur
Qurbaani ke 4 Din hone par.
[Yeh Kaha ka Insaaf hai].

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s